Scientists and energy experts are questioning the viability of Canada ‘s ambitious green hydrogen export plans, particularly those centered in Atlantic Canada. Recent developments suggest that the path to profitable green hydrogen production may be more challenging than initially anticipated.
Newfoundland Company Shifts Strategy Amid Market Uncertainties
World Energy GH2, a leading player in Canada’s green hydrogen race, recently announced plans to diversify into data centers while awaiting European market development. This strategic pivot raises questions about the feasibility of Canada’s green hydrogen export goals.
Expert Analysis Questions Economic Viability
Paul Martin, chemical engineer and co-founder of the Hydrogen Science Coalition, highlights significant challenges:
- Energy losses occur at multiple conversion stages
- High costs accumulate throughout the production and transportation process
- Current economic models show limited profit potential
“The notion that German buyers will pay premium prices for Atlantic Canadian wind-generated hydrogen isn’t economically reasonable,” Martin explains.
Infrastructure and Investment Challenges
Dr. Nick Mercer, environmental studies professor at the University of Prince Edward Island, points to several key obstacles:
- Massive infrastructure requirements
- Substantial capital investment needs
- Limited market readiness
Market Development and Future Prospects
The Canadian Climate Institute’s analysis reveals that profitable scenarios for Atlantic Canadian green ammonia exports are highly optimistic. Dale Beugin, the institute’s executive vice-president, notes that success would require “everything to go right.”
Current Project Status
Several major developments are underway:
- World Energy GH2’s Project Nujio’qonik awaits final investment decision in late 2025
- EverWind Fuels continues pursuing European buyer agreements
- Newfoundland government reviews multiple wind-to-hydrogen proposals
- Decision expected on Exploits Valley Renewable Energy Corporation project
Alternative Applications
Energy experts suggest potential alternative uses for Atlantic Canada’s green hydrogen:
- Replacing fossil fuel-based ammonia in fertilizer production
- Supporting Nova Scotia’s power grid transition from coal
- Meeting domestic clean energy needs
Government Support and Investment
The federal government offers significant support through:
- Clean hydrogen initiative tax credits
- Coverage of up to 40% of project costs
- International agreements for market development
Industry Response
While some companies maintain optimism, others are adapting their strategies. EverWind Fuels spokesperson Rudee Gaudet emphasizes that “building a robust green energy supply chain takes time,” citing the need to align production, infrastructure, and regulations across regions.
This evolving situation highlights the complex challenges facing Canada’s green hydrogen industry as it seeks to establish itself in the global clean energy market.
Read More: Scotland Sets 3.3M Tonne Green Hydrogen Production Goal
